Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Juggernut

LSP CENSORSHIP??

Recommended Posts

As painful as these threads are for some people, I think they serve a useful purpose. They provide honest feedback & allow open discussion of how people feel about the forum, good & bad. I really don't see a problem with that, we are all adults. This type of honest airing is good in the long run, it allows people to let off steam and is a decent gauge of where the membership stands on certain issues.

 

People will decide to leave, because it's just not what they want from a forum. But it clears the air to an extent and offers the mods an idea of where perhaps some people don't agree with them.

 

The answer may well be, "that's the way it is, there are other forums available". And that's absolutely fine, because it restates what LSP is all about and allows the mods the opportunity to speak about their perspective, which is rarely aired.

 

I think it's all healthy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Try to please everyone and no one will like it.

 

A while ago, one of the mods sent me a PM informing me that he had deleted my signature (Cops...the biggest street gang in the world) because someone found it offensive. Did I have a hissy fit and storm out because I had been censored? Nope. I told him I really didn't care and my signature now informs people that I'm not posting a new signature because someone found my last one offensive. Life is too short and I have more pressing issues to deal with.

And I had received a note from an individual who found my profile picture offensive.

A movie character played by Clint Eastwood! Supposedly a gun toting old west preacher in a movie was bad, he was offended.

I removed it

It wasn't a Mod.

I only did it to prevent another bloody sch*t storm

Edited by Clunkmeister

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As painful as these threads are for some people, I think they serve a useful purpose. They provide honest feedback & allow open discussion of how people feel about the forum, good & bad. I really don't see a problem with that, we are all adults. This type of honest airing is good in the long run, it allows people to let off steam and is a decent gauge of where the membership stands on certain issues.

 

People will decide to leave, because it's just not what they want from a forum. But it clears the air to an extent and offers the mods an idea of where perhaps some people don't agree with them.

 

The answer may well be, "that's the way it is, there are other forums available". And that's absolutely fine, because it restates what LSP is all about and allows the mods the opportunity to speak about their perspective, which is rarely aired.

 

I think it's all healthy.

And I'm inclined to agree with that...

 

Seconded!  :)

 

Iain

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What I don't agree with is seemingly arbitrary ham-fisted censorship based on personal likes, dislikes or tolerance. 

 

That may be how you perceive it, but you are categorically wrong. There are two sides to this, perhaps you should try to take a look from the other side, and reflect.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That may be how you perceive it, but you are categorically wrong. There are two sides to this, perhaps you should try to take a look from the other side, and reflect.

 

And I disagree...  I am very capable of seeing both side of any issue and thank you very much for the condescending suggestion. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And I had received a note from an individual who found my profile picture offensive.

A movie character played by Clint Eastwood! Supposedly a gun toting old west preacher in a movie was bad, he was offended.

I removed it

It wasn't a Mod.

I only did it to prevent another bloody sch*t storm

 

Put it back, I can't work out which are your posts now

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Guys, a Mod's response here brought back a thought of mine.

 

Regarding the original review thread, I was concerned it could get off track and voiced my concern to Brian, Ron and others in PMs.

I SPECIFICALLY stated my concerns and asked that if it descended to the schitstorm to please delete the thread or at the very least, prune it and keep it on topic.

 

I, as the OP, was one of the Members who asked at the beginning. If I had the ability to prune it myself, I would have, but I don't.

I missed the storm because I was at a retreat.

I return and the pit of hell had opened up.

 

I for one regret this whole thing. I thought the reviews thread was a good, honest, decent thread with the intention of having good conversation. I used a way out there review ascan extreme example. Prolly shouldn't have used that one, but it proved my point.

Now it's too late

 

Peace

Edited by Clunkmeister

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been a mod here since 2007, a very active one during my tenor here as well.  I'd like to think I've played some roll in making the LSP forums the place they are today.  Respectful, polite, helpful.

 

I don't view my actions nor other staffs actions as censorship. We make our calls as best as we can for the collective good of the site.  I support Iain's call in hiding that thread as a wise move.  I locked the second thread. I was a rather rash in my first post but immediately changed my comment within a minute or two.  For that I apologize,  for locking the thread I do not.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank You Iain, I was following the initial topic and the way how it slipped sideways, what I had in mind the     Oh Rats! Who screwed the Reviews Topic??    . Is there perhaps a possibility to hide conflicting posts and preserve the valuable parts of the discussion ?

 

Also I understand that there was a post removed from Maru's topic, where Ernie was relating to Biblic prophesy of Jesus fasting in the wilderness.  I know that Ernie and Maru are very close on personal level and Quran recognizes Jesus as a prophet and I am 99.9% sure that Ern would never even remotely tried to hurt Maru, no way. So why it was deleted?

 

Ron. I am looking for moderating feedback here, not for righteous attitude of wasting life as a mod. etc...., this discussion is very important for the LSP community as a whole and clarity is a must. Maybe it would be a good idea to send a PM to the member, with notification of what rule was violated and where.

Tension created by misplaced statements takes it's tool on the members as well. I am often trying to defuse the pressure by posting bunch of silly/immature statements or memes,  just to deal with it

 

I also believe that everyone appreciates Moderators and their work here as much as everyone appreciates the membership it self , however nobody holds people to stay , on both sides.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Guys, a Mod's response here brought back a thought of mine.

 

Regarding the original review thread, I was concerned it could get off track and voiced my concern to Brian, Ron and others in PMs.

I SPECIFICALLY stated my concerns and asked that if it descended to the schitstorm to please delete the thread or at the very least, prune it and keep it on topic.

 

I, as the OP, was one of the Members who asked at the beginning. If I had the ability to prune it myself, I would have, but I don't.

I missed the storm because I was at a retreat.

I return and the pit of hell had opened up.

 

I for one regret this whole thing. I thought the reviews thread was a good, honest, decent thread with the intention of having good conversation. I used a way out there review ascan extreme example. Prolly shouldn't have used that one, but it proved my point.

Now it's too late

 

Peace

 

When I last saw your thread it seemed to be ticking along nicely. I missed the descent into anarchy so I can't comment on that. From what I saw, I don't think you are to blame

 

RE: your avatar - this seems somehow appropriate:

 

clint-eastwood-and-lee-marvin-in-paint-y

 

Richard

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I totally agree that this sort of "airing of greivances" can be a good thing, and we can all learn a few things if we keep the subtle digs out of it.

 

I still believe this is the best forum I've ever been involved in, and we have very good mods whose work I greatly appreciate. They are as imperfect as we are, and don't always make the right call, and we sometimes say stupid crap we shouldn't. This kind of thing can help us all correct the course, so take it for that and keep going.

 

I do not want to see guys like Smitty and Juggernut leave over this. I'm looking forward to meeting Smitty, Out2gtcha, and many others at Nats, and this is the place that made that happen. Please remember that you may be seeing these people in person at some point, so talk to them like your looking them in the eye. Dont turn this into Facebook, please.

 

Just my 2 cents, but this place is very important to me.

 

Tim

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×