Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Really great work. Like the concept of creating your own kit if none are good enough for it.  Can't wait to see it created and on the desk

 

 

Matt  :frantic:

Posted

what an incredible build Hubert - fascinating too..

 

looks like the modelling bar is being reset.... :goodjob:

 

..bravo

 

Peter

 

Hey, Peter, this is what I am saying everytime I see YOUR work. My bar is a lot lower than yours ... ;)

 

Really great work. Like the concept of creating your own kit if none are good enough for it.  Can't wait to see it created and on the desk

 

 

Matt  :frantic:

 

 

Mee too, Matt, Can't wait  ....

 

I have ordered the engines from two companies, each equipped with one of the two high-res printers I have chosen as an alternative buy for my company ... Gotta say the price for those is steep (think about 10 or 15 Vector ones, or more than a KH B-17 :mental: ). But this is an industrial proof-of-concept. It will show me how fine one can go, and how long it takes. The options after that are to stick to the direct print-and-sell idea, or to use the printed parts as masters for some resin-casting ...

 

Thanks for following along.

 

Hubert

Posted (edited)

Exciting project, Hubert! Looking forward to seeing the 3D printed parts!

 

 

Large Scale sci-Fi, most impressive work Hubert. Absolutely epic example of skill ingenuity and determination. Bravo!

M.

 

Thank you for your support, Ray and Martin :).

 

Well ray, you wanted to see some parts, your wish (as mine) is going to be fulfilled). I got this in my company's mail this morning. This was printed on a Hi-Res 3D printer using a 50 microns UV laser-beam for the layers.

 

I was so excited I took the pics with my iPhone. The pics are big, but the enlargement is a good way of seeing the quality of the surface detail.

 

The engine block :

 

IMG_0166_zpsf5njsoyq.jpg

 

IMG_0167_zpsmmwcsu9u.jpg

 

The spikes you see on the rear of the pushrods are what's left of the support of the push rods in the printing process. They are needed as the printer cannot print a layer in 'thin air", without a connection with a preceding layer.

 

The cylinders with a small part of a cleaned-up ignition harness (look at the fins' definition on the head - they are 0.2 mm thick :) ) :

 

IMG_0168_zpsv7fw3ynj.jpg

 

IMG_0169_zpskkfeacne.jpg

 

The ignition harness, still with its printing support, to give you an idea of the printing constraints:

 

IMG_0171_zpsgpzazjfx.jpg

 

Another (blurred, as the iPhone could not focus properly that close, sorry) of the rear of the cylinders, where you can (just) discern the hole in the middle of the exhausts - the lower hole is for inserting the tabs of the intake manifold printed with the engine block

 

IMG_0170_zps7s2ex3no.jpg

 

The ruler you see is a standard 30-centimeters one, to give you a sense a proportion. On one of the cylinders pics, you have also a glimpse ofthe tip of my fat thumb, for another proportion idea :rofl:.

 

I think the result is more than convincing, technically at least. I made it difficult to print on purpose, to see how fine things could be, and the result is at par with my expectations. For a production printing run, I would probably print the exhausts and intake manifolds separately, and no push rods at all (just the holes for inserting some suitable diameter plastic or metal rods).

Now the cost for this trial is high (that is an understatement - two engines like this one would buy you an HPH Catalina or Concorde), so it remains to decide whether this printing is compatible with an economically sensible business proposition, with the idea of selling printed engines.

 

Another trial should arrive this week, done with another machine, for comparison. I'll also have a go at silicone-molding one of these for resin-casting trials.

 

In the meantime, I have conquered, in part, the "lofting monster" of Solidworks. I have achieved a better, and smoother, rudder, after many hours of trial and error; pics later when I find more time.

 

Hubert.

Edited by MostlyRacers
Posted

Hubert,

 

unbelievable to see what is possible with todays technology!!! Though the price seems to be enormous :unsure:

Can you tell which printer was used, and what only one single cylinder would cost with this technology?

 

I'm more and more interested in 3d printing, and I'm playing with the idea to eventually buy a rather "cheap" fdm-printer (maybe the Ultimaker 2 for about 2.200 €), but I guess something incredible fine like seen on your photos won't be possible with such a consumer-device.

 

Cheers

Alex

Posted (edited)

Hubert,

 

unbelievable to see what is possible with todays technology!!! Though the price seems to be enormous :unsure:

Can you tell which printer was used, and what only one single cylinder would cost with this technology?

 

I'm more and more interested in 3d printing, and I'm playing with the idea to eventually buy a rather "cheap" fdm-printer (maybe the Ultimaker 2 for about 2.200 €), but I guess something incredible fine like seen on your photos won't be possible with such a consumer-device.

 

Cheers

Alex

 

Hello Alex,

 

The printer is a DWS 20X. The quote I have for the machine is around 35 K€  VAT excluded... OK for a company (and even then I need to convince the shareholder - me - that the investment is worthwile and can be recouped ), but out of range for the average modeller. That is why I need to check the printing time to evaluate if I can charge an acceptable price / hourly rate ...

 

These printers (the hi-res ones) can print small size objects (the DWS has a 130 x 130 mm printing area and it is one of the largest on the market). The level of detail will influence the cost obviously.

To answer specifically your question, printing just one cylinder is doable, of course ... As for the cost, you need to send a file to get a quote from the players on the market (not me, ... yet).

 

The DWS printer has a laser-beam that scans the printed area of each layer (and each layer is probably around 25 microns thick). Other printers project a video-image of each layer. Inherently probably faster than the laser, but the printing area for a 40 or 50 microns resolution is smaller, sometimes as small as 30 x 40 mm. At 50 microns diameter for a laser beam, this compares to a 43x43 microns pixel for a video machine ...

 

A FDM machine is not able to reproduce this level of detail, and the layering is visible - more or less according to the machines. Although it is a very good machine, I would not choose an Ultimaker 2, as it is limited to one nozzle only (I did check recently). A two-nozzles functionality is a must for such a machine, if you want to print hollow parts with significant overhang. This way, you can print the part in ABS through one nozzle, and extrude a support material (PVA, soluble in water) with the other nozzle, which you will remove when the printing is finished.

 

For the budget-range of the Ultimaker 2, I would recommend a Felix machine. Simple and effective, and compatible with a desk/home office environment.

 

http://www.felixprinters.com/

 

Now some side-by-side comparisons between my scratchbuilt work and the printed output for the engine parts :

 

DSC01038_zpschhatzsy.jpg

 

DSC01039_zpsvogbykhk.jpg

 

DSC01041_zpsu5n1gkk8.jpg

 

DSC01040_zpsyqm7qa91.jpg

 

The verdict is simple : the 3D printer wins hands down in terms of finesse and regularity ... but the hand work is not that bad (notwithstanding the fact that the respective dimensions of the crankacse and cylinders are more accurate in the digital version, a function of more research ...), considering the price of one vs the other for the time being ;). 3D printing has still to progress to replace definitely some old modelling skills B)

 

Hubert

Edited by MostlyRacers
Posted

Hi Hubert,

 

Thank you for the in depth look at what a high fidelity 3d machine is capable of. Notwithstanding the cost, those parts are exquisite.... I certainly did not think the quality could be that good, but I guess it was only a matter of time before technology caught up. 

 

Noting the cost, where exactly is the expense in the printing process? I wouldn't have thought the consumable material would be overly expensive (perhaps it is), or is it more in the massive original cost of the machine?

 

Glad to hear you were able to overcome some of your issues with the design software. I know from experience it is not easy, and many a time, something that I swear I've done before will simply not work and frustratingly you have to find a new way to "skin the cat."

 

Very impressive mate, I look forward to seeing more :)

 

Craig

Posted

Cool! That 3D printing is outstanding. All we need now is for the cost to come down. Nice CAD work, Hubert!

Guest Clunkmeister
Posted

That's gorgeous, Harold. I've said it before, but if I was allowed to choose one single seater sportplane from the late 20s/early 30s, this little plane would be it.

In my opinion, real one was an absolute work of modern art. Just gorgeous without a straight line anywhere on her.

I'd just park her in my garage, and wash, wax, shine and stare at her all day long.

On nice days, I'd pull her out into the sunshine to gleam like a jewel, and then take her for a ride.

Maybe open her up and let her strut her stuff.

I'm just smitten by the Mystery Ship!

Posted

Droooool :)

  

Hubert,

 

INSPIRATIONAL work which has reached the dizzying heights of technological workmanship... :bow:

 

INCREDIBLY IMPRESSIVE work.. :clap2: :clap2:  { LOVE the Engine.. :wub:  }

 

you ROCK !! :punk: :punk:

  

Hi Hubert,

 

Thank you for the in depth look at what a high fidelity 3d machine is capable of. Notwithstanding the cost, those parts are exquisite.... I certainly did not think the quality could be that good, but I guess it was only a matter of time before technology caught up. 

 

Noting the cost, where exactly is the expense in the printing process? I wouldn't have thought the consumable material would be overly expensive (perhaps it is), or is it more in the massive original cost of the machine?

 

Glad to hear you were able to overcome some of your issues with the design software. I know from experience it is not easy, and many a time, something that I swear I've done before will simply not work and frustratingly you have to find a new way to "skin the cat."

 

Very impressive mate, I look forward to seeing more :)

 

Craig

  

Cool! That 3D printing is outstanding. All we need now is for the cost to come down. Nice CAD work, Hubert!

Thank you guys :). Much appareciated.

 

The resins, especially proprietary ones, are not cheap, with a few hundred € per kilo, but in this case the actual consumption is worth only a few euros. The main cost component is the amortization of the machine, translated to an hourly rate, times the number of hours for printing. If you print a 25 microns layer, a 50 mm high part will have 2000 layers. Assuming 20" per layer, that is 11 hours printing time, but 16 if it takes 30" to "impress" a layer.

 

I have seen a new machine is being developed, using a combination of UV and selective oxygen release, that promises to divise the time by 20 or 50 ...

 

I am still after obtaining the actual printing time for these parts, not to détermine the mark-up of my supplier, but to understand the long-term economics ...

 

Hubert

Posted (edited)

You have brought tears to my eyes from the fantastic little plane you are bring to life.

 

I just can't help myself, here is a little 1/48 scale "what if" I did many years ago.

 

FTA-1%20Puffin_zpsbcugkf1f.jpg

That's gorgeous, Harold. I've said it before, but if I was allowed to choose one single seater sportplane from the late 20s/early 30s, this little plane would be it.

In my opinion, real one was an absolute work of modern art. Just gorgeous without a straight line anywhere on her.

I'd just park her in my garage, and wash, wax, shine and stare at her all day long.

On nice days, I'd pull her out into the sunshine to gleam like a jewel, and then take her for a ride.

Maybe open her up and let her strut her stuff.

I'm just smitten by the Mystery Ship!

Remember, Ernie - wax on, wax off.

Lovely what-if, Harold :goodjob:

 

I hope the finished new Mystery Ship will live up to expectations I am creating ;).

 

As I have said, LSM' s MS can be turned into a nice - if not totally accurate - replica. But I am in the "anal-retentive, rivet-counting, nitpicking" camp :).

This is turning into a great personal learning experience, anyway.

 

Hubert

 

PS: not much progress for the time being. Have taken a week off in Tuscany, where I chose to be sick and stay in bed ... Today, I will try to see if Chianti is a better remedy B)

Edited by MostlyRacers

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...