Hubert Boillot Posted October 2, 2015 Author Posted October 2, 2015 (edited) Hubert. Amazing work and completely enjoying following your progress Keep 'em coming Peter Me too! Kev Your tread reads like a thesis on the art of modeling and employing new technologies, Hubert. I really enjoy following it along! Cheers, Hans Thank you Peter, Kev and Hans . I am flattered that you find this interesting. @ Hans, sometimes I feel this could read as a treaty on modelling blunders because you rush into something without initial pausing ... Anyhow, some digital progress ... I confess that, if sometimes I do not know what I am embarking on in modelling, it is even truer with Solidworks. There is a (steep) learning curve to master this software, and I cannot pretend I have succeeded so far. I am very often wasting a lot of time trying to master its functionalities, and even more understading its sometimes cryptic error messages. Then I resort to some trial and error method I have for instance not found a way to use the "shell" function with mùy designed fuselage, and had to come back trying to blend the sections whilst designing the fuselage shell thickness in them. The blend fuction produced some weird internal shapes. In the end, I decided that, if it printed OK on the outside, then a good grinder and some sandpaper would smooth out the inside . itto for the Karman fairing. The 3D design is lacking, but a file will shape the printed part into submission. So here is what my left, digital fuselage looks like. The pinching-in of the fuselage at the level of the cockpit is well visible in the second pic. I have tried to "assemble" the engine and the fuselage to check whether it made sense. The good news is that the sizes are consistent. However, methink that maybe my front fuselage is a bit too long. I need to design the cowling and put it in place to verify what corrections are needed. By the way, the LSM cowling will not fit the new fuselage and the new engine : its diameter is too small ... When I am finished, I am not sure what will be left of the original kit, if anything. The more I think of it, the more my work may end-up as masters for a new "Mystery Ship" kit Hubert. Edited October 2, 2015 by MostlyRacers
Hubert Boillot Posted October 6, 2015 Author Posted October 6, 2015 Thanks Loïc. Good to see you back here, mate ! Some progress. I have designed the cowling and the fairing that comes above the engine's reduction gear carter and ignition harness. One wonders why I did these at all, but, in fact, a tiny bit of it is visible I have also retouched the fuselage. Once the cowling was in place, the front fuselage length appeared OK, but the shape needed some touching-up. In the process, I have also done small amendments to the tail, and added the rear skid's fairing. I am still struggling to master the fairing functions of Solidworks, and could not re-produce the fairing for the rear Karman. But, as I said in a previous post, if this can be printed, then some filling, sanding, and filing will take care of my computer inadequacies . One of the many magical features of CAD is the "symetry" function. Once the left fuselage seemed OK, producing the right one was a matter of seconds Certainly faster than my re-doing it on the kit ... So here is what the two halves assembled together should look like : And with the engine, cowling and reduction gear case fairing in place : I wil continue with creating the outer wing panels, the stabilisers, the elevators and the rudder ... If this is still OK, I will then "just" have to design the interior tubular structure, the various cockpit details, including the seat, the undercarriage parts and the prop and I will have all the parts for a better (read more accurate-to-my-liking ) Mystery Ship than the original kit. This is typically where the debate between "looks about right" (the LSM kit as it is) and "I want an accurate version" takes place all the time about new kits. A lot will be happy to have the LSM kit (which is worth having for the decal sheet alone, as I stated in my first post), as I was when I started this thread. For those who will want a more accurate Mystery Ship, hopefully I will be able to transform the design into a kit ... More to come, when possible. Hubert Out2gtcha and Leaning_Dog 2
Hubert Boillot Posted October 12, 2015 Author Posted October 12, 2015 (edited) A quick update ... after some not-so-quick work. Finished designing the wings. They were a PITA to design, because of my lack of skill on Solidworks, mostly. I spent a few hours trying to blend the wing-fillets, to no avail ... Until I realised that the software was not stupid, but me , asking it to perform too complex functions with too little data. And that the wing profile was prolonged across the span, even when the chord decreases because of the elliptical plan-view of the wing-fillet. Things went more smoothly from there, even though I had to do a bit of expedient "cheating" on the last bits of the fillet. Done the horizontal stabs as well. Here is how the virtual model looks like now : The elevators and rudder should be fairly easy next ... Hubert PS: when all the CAD-work is completed, and IF the 3D printing is working to plan, I will most likely start a new thread, dealing with building the new kit, from the newly created parts ... Edited October 12, 2015 by MostlyRacers Leaning_Dog and Lars Befring 2
Wolf Buddee Posted October 12, 2015 Posted October 12, 2015 Wow Hubert, this definitely takes modelling in to a whole new realm. It's exciting and daunting all at the same time. It's also incredibly interesting to watch. Way to go........ Cheers, Wolf
OldTroll Posted October 12, 2015 Posted October 12, 2015 Brilliant design work. Looking forward to the kit.
brahman104 Posted October 13, 2015 Posted October 13, 2015 This is some truly epic stuff you're doing here Hubert! I've just been reading the whole topic from start to now and you've had some really creative solutions to problems going on here which is awesome to see. Your initial approach for the cooling fins on the engine using the silhouette cutter was really cool, that could even be an answer to my issue of etching brass for rib detail..... Amazing project mate, loving your work! Craig
Hubert Boillot Posted October 13, 2015 Author Posted October 13, 2015 (edited) Wow Hubert, this definitely takes modelling in to a whole new realm. It's exciting and daunting all at the same time. It's also incredibly interesting to watch. Way to go........ Cheers, Wolf Brilliant design work. Looking forward to the kit. This is some truly epic stuff you're doing here Hubert! I've just been reading the whole topic from start to now and you've had some really creative solutions to problems going on here which is awesome to see. Your initial approach for the cooling fins on the engine using the silhouette cutter was really cool, that could even be an answer to my issue of etching brass for rib detail..... Amazing project mate, loving your work! Craig Thank you Ron, Wolf and Craig . I have to admit my mind was not initially set on doing a 3D CAD work. It grew on me when I started thinking about re-making an accurate 5-view drawing for the bird, to guide my modifying of the LSM kit. It just dawned on me that making 2D drawings in one dimension, and then another in another dimension, was just what Solidworks was capable of ... For the engine, the solution of using the Silhouette is still there as a backup. I have the heads and exhaust valve fairings all assembled. I proved it could work when re-doing the front cylinder of the Menasco of my Fisher ST-M. So the solution exists should the printing fail. Here again, it dawned on me, as I had redone the cranckase, and was about to change the cylinders, and since I was not initially too sure about the way the exhaust port was located on the head, that drawing it was a way of firming-up my mind. I fine-tuned the relations in designing the engine on Solidworks, as things became obvious. And the idea was that maybe someone more than just me could be interested in a correct engine for the LSM kit. The idea of 3D printing the fuselage parts came after I saw some more convincing (i.e. where the layering was less obvious) FDM machines in professional fairs. I am about to invest in a high-resolution 3D printer for my company, but, whereas they are OK for things like engine parts, or small details, the available print area is not adequate for fuselages or wing-panels, even for a small aircraft like the Mystery Ship (the machine I have set my views on has a 130mmx130mm printing area, and it is one the biggest available for a machine below 50 000 €). If the printing does not work, I have all the equipment in my company to mill some blocks of aluminium into shape anyway. They would then serve as masters for female vac-forming molds. So I guess this design work will not be wasted @ Craig : I did not think of using the Silhouette for your B-17 bomb bay formers, but, yes, it is workable if you have one. And the software that comes with it is good enough for a lot of needs, and very easy to master. Stay tuned. Hubert Edited October 13, 2015 by MostlyRacers
Hubert Boillot Posted October 13, 2015 Author Posted October 13, 2015 (edited) Thank you my friend. Glad you like it ! Hubert Edited October 13, 2015 by MostlyRacers
ClumsyDude Posted October 13, 2015 Posted October 13, 2015 I have so much respect for you guys who can work with 3D software ... reading these threads is giving me a sense of just how difficult it is to achieve a good result. Great work Hubert, keep it up! Jim scvrobeson 1
Ironwing Posted October 17, 2015 Posted October 17, 2015 Hu, Your approach to this is just lights out, a truly interesting and complete tutorial. I hope youll continue to post. Ground breaking work my friend. I know its at times difficult and irritating. Stay the course. Best Geoff
Hubert Boillot Posted October 17, 2015 Author Posted October 17, 2015 I have so much respect for you guys who can work with 3D software ... reading these threads is giving me a sense of just how difficult it is to achieve a good result. Great work Hubert, keep it up! Jim Hu, Your approach to this is just lights out, a truly interesting and complete tutorial. I hope youll continue to post. Ground breaking work my friend. I know its at times difficult and irritating. Stay the course. Best Geoff Thank you Jim and Geoff . A bit of a pause as I fight the brain-fog of the first cold of the season ... Another frustrating session designing the rudder. I KNOW the software is capable of doing the complex 3-directional compound shape of the rudder, but I just cannot work my way around the instructions to get a smooth shape Ended cheating with half-satisfactory attempts at going around the blockage, but, even though It would be completely possible to sand printed parts to the desired shape, I want to find the software solution ! Hubert
Guest Peterpools Posted October 17, 2015 Posted October 17, 2015 Geez! and as Wolf said, takes the hobby to a new level and discipline. Sure wish I had the skills and knowledge to dive in but at my age and computer skills, just keeping my Mac humming is an accomplishment. Keep 'em coming Peter
airscale Posted October 17, 2015 Posted October 17, 2015 what an incredible build Hubert - fascinating too.. looks like the modelling bar is being reset.... ..bravo Peter
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now